Skip to main content

EFCore - Update command is not updating the underlying data

Why my update command using EFCore is not updating the underlying data in the database though in middle-tier code it's successful, not throwing any error?

Let's try to get the root cause and how to solve this. 

When creating the model class of related database object if the primary key name is Id then no need to explicitly mention the Key in ef-core OnModelCreating. 

But if we've key name different from Id then we have to explicitly mention it in our OnModelCreating.

Something like this:

 entity.HasKey(c => new {c.CustId });

Assume in the database we've Customers table like this:

CREATE TABLE [dbo].[Customers](
	[CustId] [INT] IDENTITY(1,1) NOT NULL Primary Key,
	[FirstName] [VARCHAR](50) NULL
)

Point to ponder: In the database table, column CustId is already defined as Primary key. 

In EFCore model setup, it's up to us to configure the Key as (custId) or configure it as HasNoKey()


Assume we've set our entity with HasNoKey()

Customer-Model-HasNoKey
  
protected override void OnModelCreating(ModelBuilder modelBuilder)
{   
	modelBuilder.Entity(entity =>
	{
		// Here we're not setting kay key to EFCore model.
		entity.HasNoKey();

		entity.Property(e => e.FirstName)
			.HasMaxLength(50)
			.IsUnicode(false);
	});
	OnModelCreatingPartial(modelBuilder);
}

  

 And executed the command to update Customers entity using  EFCore code

EfCore code snippet:

var customer = _dbContext.Customers.Where(x => x.CustId == 1).FirstOrDefault();
customer.FirstName = "Updated name - with primary key";
_dbContext.SaveChanges();

 Then trying to update the Customers entity from EFCore code base, related entries value in the database will not change.  Here is the screen is shown before & after executing the ef-core code.



Now let's try to add the primary key in Customers model and then update 

Customer-Model-HasKey

protected override void OnModelCreating(ModelBuilder modelBuilder)
{
	modelBuilder.Entity(entity =>
	{
		// define your key here.
		entity.HasKey(c => new {c.CustId });

		entity.Property(e => e.FirstName)
			.HasMaxLength(50)
			.IsUnicode(false);
	});
	OnModelCreatingPartial(modelBuilder);
}

and now execute the same EfCore code to update the customers' entity and verify in the database, yes, out data got updated. 


Conclusion:

In EFCore if it good to have primary key explicitly defined (if it's not Id) in our model, otherwise at runtime we may come across a situation like this (update not happening, sorting not working....)



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

EFCore - Collate function

Search in SQL server query is generally case insensitive (by default or based on database level collation). Suppose we have an employees table with a row having first-name column value as "My-First-Name", so if we want to do the case-sensitive search we have to explicitly use the related collate: In EF 5 (currently in Release Candidate version [RC.2.20475.6]) Collate function got introduced which helps us to use our specific collation based search.  C# with EF5 code sample: var employeeCaseSensitiveSearch = _dbContext.Employees .Where(x => EF.Functions.Collate(x.FirstName, "Latin1_General_CS_AS") == "my-first-name") .FirstOrDefault(); A related database query will be something like this: T-SQL: Case sensitive search (use specific collation e.g.: Latin1_General_CS_AS) SELECT * FROM dbo.Employees AS e WHERE e.FirstName Collate Latin1_General_CS_AS = 'my-first-name' Some of the useful CSharp function which g...

Azure SQL - AAD Authentication from you client application in user context

When we try to migrate our IaaS SQL to Azure SQL along with other code changes & refactoring, one of the most prominent things that come into the picture is Authentication through a client application (web app or windows form, excel-add-ins...). With IaaS/OnPrem SQL we could use Windows Authentication to let your client application interact with the SQL server with the user's context. But to Azure SQL we can't do the Windows Authentication and also we should avoid SQL-based login (user/password).  To login to Azure SQL, it's always preferable to use Azure Active Directory-based authentication (integrated flow, MFA, or AAD based password). Now the problem comes how to achieve this with your client application.  The solution to this problem statement is, u se AAD app with delegated permission to access the users' claim [email, sid] in access token & configure it based on your client (e.g. windows form, web application) Here are ...

EFCore - Scaffold-DbContext how to use

EFCore versions, we don't have GUI to manage the DB-entities & dbContext like we used to have with EF6 (or EF5/4 version). With EFCore we've the Scaffold-DbContext command which helps us to create entities & DB context from our DB-objects.  Let's see how to use Scaffold-DbContext: Assume we're connecting with SQL Server so after creating a sample project you'll have to install EFCore related libraries as mentioned below.  Install entity-framework-core for SQL Server, at this time 3.1.9 is the latest stable version   Microsoft.EntityFrameworkcore   Microsoft.EntityFrameworkCore.SqlServer  To use Scaffold-DbContext, following two NuGet packages are required Microsoft.EntityFrameworkCore.Tools  Microsoft.EntityFrameworkCore.Design Let's say we've two DB tables (e.g. dbo.Employees & dbo.Users )  Now let's see how to use Scaffold-DbContext to create c-...